(17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
|
05-30-2024, 12:24 AM
Post: #21
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Hi, Gil
We need bank APY because payment growth is on yearly basis, but compounding is monthly. If payment growth is also on a monthly basis, we don't need effective rate. lua> s, i, pv = 1.075, 0.01, 6e4 lua> USPV = fn'i,n: -expm1(log1p(i)*-n) / i' -- = 1 / cn lua> s1 = tvm(12, nil, -1, 0, s) -- APY to monthly rate q = (1+s1)/(1+i) --> q-1 = (s1-i)/(1+i) pv/pmt = (1 + q + q^2 + ... + q^59) / -c1 + q^60 / -c300 lua> tvm(60, (s1-i)/(1+i), USPV(i,300), USPV(i,1), nil) -- = pv/pmt -128.065884851857 lua> pv / _ -- = pmt -468.50884659412856 |
|||
05-30-2024, 01:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-30-2024 01:37 AM by Gil.)
Post: #22
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Sorry, Albert, but I am starting to be confused now!
PV 60000 FV 0 IG%YR 7.5% with growth of the payments during 5 years, from years 2-6, then all the following payements remain constant at level of year 6. But, in your example, what is your compounding/YR, C/YR? And what is here, for your calculation, the annual nominal interest, I%/YR? And payments always at the end/beginning of the period? For C/Yr = 3, P/yr=12, end-payments, I find -468.087113114. Until your last reply, Albert, I was pretty sure of my way of calculating, only using — based on the annual given nominal rate I%YR — the corresponding effective rate, in my case here r=[(1 + 12/3/100)^3]^(1/12)=1.00985340655, for monthly payments. |
|||
05-30-2024, 02:11 AM
Post: #23
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
(05-30-2024 01:08 AM)Gil Wrote: But, in your example, what is your compounding/YR, C/YR? P/Yr = C/Yr = 12 --> bank rate = APR 12% --> monthly rate i = 1% Payment mode = END (s-1) = APY 7.5%, converted to monthly rate s1 = 1.075^(1/12) - 1 ≈ 0.6045% pmt1 = pmt = -468.50884659412856 (calculated from my previous post) pmt2 = pmt * (1+s1) pmt3 = pmt * (1+s1)^2 ... pmt60 = pmt * (1+s1)^59 Mortgage compounding and payment growth are in sync, with equivalent rate: (q-1) = (1+s1)/(1+i) - 1 = (s1-i)/(1+i) pmt61 = pmt * (1+s1)^60, and stay there until loan get paid off (pmt360). (05-25-2024 08:40 PM)Albert Chan Wrote: lua> r = -1 / c300 -- = pv6/pmt6 Confirm pmt (grow monthly until pmt61) without using (q-1), simply loops. lua> i, s1 0.01 0.006044919024291704 lua> r = tvm(300,i,nil,1,0) -- = -1 / c300 lua> d1 = 1 lua> c1 = d1 + i lua> for loops=1,60 do r = (d1*r*(1+s1)-1) / c1 end lua> r -128.06588485185708 lua> pv / r -- = pmt -468.5088465941283 |
|||
05-30-2024, 03:14 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-30-2024 03:55 AM by Gil.)
Post: #24
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Understood.
I thought wrongly that, in graduated approach, during first year payments Pi (P1, P2... P12) = fix amount =P during the 2nd year P13, P14... P24=fix amount = P. 1.075 etc But, as I deduce from your explanations, it's not the case. I have no experience on the matter, but I am surprised that the sum to be paid back should increase regularly by 7.5% during 59 (or 60) months (very complicated for the client to see the amount change every months). Regards |
|||
05-30-2024, 12:23 PM
Post: #25
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
(05-30-2024 03:14 AM)Gil Wrote: I thought wrongly that, in graduated approach, You are right, that was how GPM is normally setup. I was just showing what happen if compounding and payment growth are in sync (monthly) We could also solve GPM payment by assuming payment is in yearly basis. This setup, compounding and payment growth are now in sync (yearly) lua> K = fn'i,n: expm1(log1p(i)*n)' -- = (1+i)^n - 1 lua> USFV = fn'i,n: K(i,n)/i' -- = 1 / dn lua> USPV = fn'i,n: -USFV(i,-n)' -- = 1 / cn lua> s, i, pv = 1.075, 0.01, 6e4 lua> I = K(i,12) -- = APY lua> tvm(5, (s-1-I)/(1+I), USPV(I,25), USPV(I,1), nil) -- = pv/pmt -9.96351503776498 lua> pmt = pv / _ lua> pmt -- yearly payment -6021.971138958528 lua> pmt / USFV(i,12) -- equivalent monthly payment -474.82512976281373 |
|||
05-30-2024, 01:25 PM
Post: #26
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Solving the Negative Amortization problem of Graduated-Payment Loans, is an interesting read.
BEST! SlideRule |
|||
05-31-2024, 01:21 PM
Post: #27
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Indeed. What the article fails to mention though, is what should be done if you want both Graduated Payments and have a minimum payment equal to the interest due?
The above equations can be used to solve for any of the other parameters, so if the initial PMT is set, we can vary another one, like G% or N (the number of times the payment grows) For the problem with M = 30 years PV = 60'000 I%Y = 12 per year N=5 (growth periods) we set PMT = -PV*I%/12 = -600 Solve for G% to see 0.80% (0.8053452), so the last 300 payments are -600*(1+G%/100)^5 = -624.55 or, take instead N=30 (let payments grow annually all through the loan - N=29 is the same BTW) Now G%= 0.40% (0.3973548653), bringing the last 12 payments to -600*(1+G%/100)^29 = -673.13 As a regular annuity, this mortgage has a constant monthly PMT of -617.17 (which, incidentally, you can also determine using this equation, setting N or G% to 0) Cheers, Werner 41CV†,42S,48GX,49G,DM42,DM41X,17BII,15CE,DM15L,12C,16CE |
|||
06-01-2024, 01:12 AM
Post: #28
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
(05-25-2024 11:52 PM)Gil Wrote: [PMT] is plain and easy. Trickier is to find i. Inspired by Werner's post of finding growth rate, we have the formula for i too. x = ((s-1)-APY) / (1+APY) tvm(N, x, USPV(i,300), USPV(i,12), nil) --> PV/PMT Now, do this in reverse, with nil replaced by PV/PMT, solve for rate x x = s / (1+APY) - 1 (1+x) * (1+APY) = s // formula for x and APY have same form! --> APY = ((s-1)-x) / (1+x) --> (s-1) = x*(1+APY) + APY To confirm math, we redo Werner's previous post, solve for growth rate (s-1) lua> K = fn'i,n: expm1(log1p(i)*n)' lua> USPV = fn'i,n: -K(i,-n)/i' lua> i = 0.01 lua> APY = K(i,12) lua> tvm(5, nil, USPV(i,300), USPV(i,12), -1/i) * (1+APY) + APY 0.008053452004141717 lua> tvm(30, nil, 0, USPV(i,12), -1/i) * (1+APY) + APY 0.003973548652941375 |
|||
06-01-2024, 10:43 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-01-2024 10:49 AM by Gil.)
Post: #29
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Yes, Chan.
The "trouble" is that I don't think that I have some of the mentioned functions as USPV in my HP50G calculator. And what if I included payments growth every two months in a year, but payments every month, but having quarterly compounding? I know: it should never happen... |
|||
06-01-2024, 11:19 AM
Post: #30
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
(06-01-2024 10:43 AM)Gil Wrote: The "trouble" is that I don't think that I have some of the mentioned functions as USPV in my HP50G calculator. 'SPFV(I%,N)=EXPM(LNP1(I%/100.)*N)+1.' DEFINE 'SPPV(I%,N)=EXPM(-LNP1(I%/100.)*N)+1.' DEFINE 'USFV(I%,N)=IFTE(I%,EXPM(LNP1(I%/100.)*N)/I%*100.,N)' DEFINE 'USPV(I%,N)=IFTE(I%,-EXPM(-LNP1(I%/100.)*N)/I%*100.,N)' DEFINE Cheers, Werner 41CV†,42S,48GX,49G,DM42,DM41X,17BII,15CE,DM15L,12C,16CE |
|||
06-01-2024, 11:57 AM
Post: #31
|
|||
|
|||
RE: (17B/19B) GPM: initial payment
Sorry, I did not pay attention initially to your formulae.
Thanks, Werner. Gil |
|||
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)