Post Reply 
HHC 2014 Programming Contest
09-25-2014, 06:12 AM
Post: #14
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest
Of the conference attendees who submitted RPN (not RPL) entries to the programming contest, my entry for the WP 34s was the worst. I don't really have that much 34s experience, so I worked on it until about 4:30 AM Sunday morning. Had I known about SDL, SDR, and RTN+1, that would have shaved off quite a few steps. I avoided a few optimizations due to the contest rules favoring elegance over trickiness. Here's the writeup I gave Joe when I submitted the entry:
Code:
HHC 2014 Programming Contest Entry
Eric Smith
For WP 34S

The output format is YYYYMMDD.

All output is done by PSE 10 (approx 1.0 sec).

NOTE: contents of X register when program terminates is not
considered an output.  It will by January 1 of the following
year, in YYYYMMDD format, regardless of whether it is prime.

Two flags are used to handle boundary conditions:
flag 01 clear when handling first month (DEC 31 of prev year, JAN 01 of specified year),
        set for all subsequent months
flag 02 set when handling thirteenth month (DEC 31 of specified year, JAN 01 of next year)

No storage registers are used.  Whether that is elegant or inelegant may be debatable.

A "SKIP 1" is used at one point after a test instruction.  Normally I would consider a
SKIP instruction inelegant, since it is an impediment to program understanding and editing.
However, a "SKIP 1" after a test instruction effectively acts as an inversion of the test,
which in my opinion is elegant.

The constant 8800 is used.  A line could be saved by coding it as "CONST #088, CONST #100, *",
but this seems inelegant.  Using another factorization such as "CONST #176, CONST #050, *"
might be even worse since that further obfuscates the value.

In comments in the listing below, mm is month, mp is previous month


01 * LBL "A"
02   MODE Y.MD
03   CFALL                                    ; init boundary condition flags

04   CONST #013                               ; init month counter
05   x<>y

06   E                ; 1 yyyy cnt
07   4                ; 1E4 yyyy cnt
08   *                ; yyyy0000 cnt
09   INC .X           ; yyyy0001 cnt
10   GTO 02
                                    
11 * LBL 01           ; yyyymm01 cnt          ; main loop
12   SF 01                                    ; mark already handled JAN 01
13   FS? 02                                   ; already handled DEC 31?
14   RTN                                      ; yes

15 * LBL 02
16   CONST #100       ; 100 yyyymm01 cnt      ; advance to next month
17   +                ; yyyymm01 cnt

18   DSZ .Y           ; yyyymm01 cnt-1        ; reached 13th month?
19   GTO 03                                   ; no, go process

20   SF 02            ;                       ; flag final month
21   8                ; 8 yyyy1301 cnt-1      ; adjust from 13th month to first month of next year
22   8                ; 88 yyyy1301 cnt-1
23   0                ; 88 yyyy1301 cnt-1
24   0                ; 8800 yyyy1301 cnt-1
25   +                ; yyyz0101 cnt-1

26 * LBL 03
27   PRIME?           ; yyyymm01 cnt          ; day 01 of month prime?
28   SKIP 1           ; yyyymm01 cnt          ; yes - SKIP 1 after test reverses sense of test
29   GTO 01           ; yyyymm01              ; no, try next month

30   RCL X            ; yyyymm01 yyyymm01 cnt ; save as potential second day of pair

                                              ; back up to last day of prev month
31   E                ; 1 yyyymm01 yyyymm01 cnt
32   4                ; 1E4 yyyymm01 yyyymm01 cnt
33   /                ; yyyy.mmdd yyyymm01 cnt
34   1                ; 1 yyyy.mmdd yyyymm01 cnt
35   CHS              ; -1 yyyy.mmdd yyyymm01 cnt
36   DAYS+            ; yyyy.mpdd yyyymm01 cnt
37   E                ; 1 yyyy.mpdd yyyymm01 cnt
38   4                ; 1E4 yyyy.mpdd yyyymm01 cnt
39   *                ; yyyympdd yyyymm01 cnt

40   PRIME?             
41   GTO 04                                   ; yes, found a pair
42   RDN              ; yyyymm01 cnt          ; no, get potential second day back
43   GTO 01                                   ; try next month

44 * LBL 04                                   ; first day of month and last day of prev month both prime
45   FS? 01           ; yyyympdd yyyymm01 cnt ; was first day Jan 1?
46   PSE 10           ; yyyympdd yyyymm01 cnt ; no, so display prev date
47   RDN              ; yyyymm01 cnt
48   FC? 02                                   ; handling DEC 31?
49   PSE 10                                   
50   GTO 01                                   ; try next month

When I finished that at 4:30 AM, I decided to have a go at an RPL version. I was convinced that I wouldn't even be in the running for RPL, and I was very tired and wanted to get some sleep before the start of the Sunday session, so I only spent half an hour on it, and didn't do even some obvious optimizations, such as replacing "3 ROLL" (which had earlier in the development been "4 ROLL") with ROT. With the benefit of hindsight, I should have stopped optimizing my 34s program around midnight and spend more time optimizing my RPL entry. My RPL entry as submitted was apparently the same length as David Hayden's winning entry as submitted. My writeup (done "by hand", so direct ASCII import to an RPL calculator will fail):

Code:
HHC 2014 Programming Contest Entry
Eric Smith
For HP 50g

The output format is YYYYMMDD.  The output will be a list left on the stack.

306.5 #2586h
<< { } SWAP                      ; yyyy {}
   1E4 *
   1 +                           ; yyyy0001 {}
   0 12 FOR i
     100 +                       ; yyyymm01 {}
     IF i 12 == THEN
       8800 +
     END
     DUP                         ; yyyymm01 yyyymm01 {}
         10000 /                            ; yyyy.mmdd
         DUP IP 1e6 /                       ; .00yyyy yyyy.mmdd
         SWAP FP 100 *                      ; mm.dd .00yyyy
         +                                  ; mm.ddyyyy
         -1 DATE+                           ; mm.ddyyyy
         100 *                              ; mmdd.yyyy
         DUP IP                             ; mmdd mmdd.yyyy
         SWAP FP                            ; .yyyy mmdd
         1e8 *                              ; yyyy0000 mmdd
         +                                  ; yyyymmdd
                                 ; yyyympdd yyyymm01 {}
       IF DUP2 ISPRIME? SWAP ISPRIME? AND THEN
         IF i 0 /= THEN
                                 ; yyyympdd yyyymm01 {}
           3 ROLL                ; {} yyyymmdd yyyymm01
           SWAP +                ; {} yyyymm01
           SWAP                  ; yyyymm01 {}
         ELSE
           DROP                  ; yyyymm01 {}
         END
         IF i 12 /= THEN
           DUP                   ; yyyymm01 yyyymm01 {}
           3 ROLL                ; {} yyyymm01 yyyymm01
           SWAP +                ; {} yyyymm01
           SWAP                  ; yyyymm01 {}
         END
       ELSE
         DROP
       END

   NEXT                          ; yyyymm01 {}
   DROP                          ; {}
>>

The final DROP is not strictly necessary, since the contest rules didn't
say that we couldn't leave extra junk on the stack.  For that matter, the
program would be slightly shorter if we just left the answers on the stack
indivdually, but if we didn't also include a count that would be rather
unfriendly.

Thanks to Joe for yet another interesting programming challenge!
Find all posts by this user
Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Messages In This Thread
HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Paul Dale - 09-24-2014, 09:13 AM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - BruceH - 10-02-2014, 09:35 PM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - brouhaha - 09-25-2014 06:12 AM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Jeff O. - 09-29-2014, 01:41 PM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Jeff O. - 09-30-2014, 04:39 PM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Jeff O. - 10-06-2014, 05:01 PM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Jeff O. - 10-07-2014, 12:26 PM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Werner - 10-03-2014, 07:35 AM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - C.Ret - 10-05-2014, 10:02 AM
RE: HHC 2014 Programming Contest - Werner - 10-05-2014, 08:02 PM



User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)