The Museum of HP Calculators

HP Forum Archive 21

[ Return to Index | Top of Index ]

What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #1 Posted by Walter B on 14 Dec 2012, 6:24 a.m.

Imagine the lower six rows of keys of our hypothetical eight-row calculator are filled with functions not listed below. Two rows are left. The following individual functions compete for the remaining space:

1/x SQRT LN e^x x^2 y^x LG 10^x i [theta] [Sigma+] [Sigma-] P>R R>P D>R R>D HR>H.MS H.MS>HR sin cos tan asin acos atan x_bar s y_hat r [parallel] % %CHG x_ROOT(y) LOG[sub_x](y) RAN# H.MS+ H.MS- x! COMB PERM ROUND DISP USER ALPHA DSE ISG ABS IP FP

What shall go there? You may specify up to 12 functions in your vote (one post only, please). You may specify them in pairs (unshifted / shifted) if you want to. You must not specify menus.

This poll will terminate on Tuesday, December 18th, at 12:12 UTC. Please participate.

d:-)

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #2 Posted by Gerson W. Barbosa on 14 Dec 2012, 6:58 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

unshifted: 1/x y^x sqrt ln sin cos tan
shifted: e^x [parallel] asin acos atan

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #3 Posted by Tim Wessman on 14 Dec 2012, 10:07 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Ans, comma, ( , ) , and =. Nothing else matters.

TW

Edited: 14 Dec 2012, 10:08 a.m.

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #4 Posted by Walter B on 14 Dec 2012, 10:10 a.m.,
in response to message #3 by Tim Wessman

Sorry, Tim, you obviously didn't read the OP thoroughly :-/

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #5 Posted by Geoff Quickfall on 14 Dec 2012, 11:15 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

P>R, R>P HMS+ HMS- IP FP

SIN COS TAN ASIN ACOS ATAN

most used in navigation formulae.

Thanks, Geoff

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #6 Posted by Maximilian Hohmann on 14 Dec 2012, 4:23 p.m.,
in response to message #5 by Geoff Quickfall

Quote:
P>R, R>P HMS+ HMS- IP FP

SIN COS TAN ASIN ACOS ATAN

most used in navigation formulae.


+1 (or in plain text: the same for me please ) :-)

max

Edited: 14 Dec 2012, 4:26 p.m.

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #7 Posted by Ethan Conner on 14 Dec 2012, 12:47 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

P>R,R>P,SQRT,x^2,%,%CHG SIN,COS,TAN,ASIN,ACOS,ATAN

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #8 Posted by Silvio A. Bensi on 14 Dec 2012, 1:07 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Shifted: [Sigma-] asin acos atan x^2 y^x Unshifted: [Sigma+] sin cos tan SQRT 1/x

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #9 Posted by Etienne Victoria on 14 Dec 2012, 1:44 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

n, i, PMT, PV, FV, %, Sigma+

... All of a sudden, I feel lonely...

Nevermind, I love your project :-)

Etienne

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #10 Posted by Reth on 14 Dec 2012, 4:47 p.m.,
in response to message #9 by Etienne Victoria

Quote:

n, i, PMT, PV, FV, %, Sigma+

... All of a sudden, I feel lonely...

Nevermind, I love your project :-)

Etienne


You must be kidding, what functions are 'n' and 'i'? What is so important about the super-complicated function '%'? What's more we are discussing here scientific calculator, not a new version of HP12B.
                  
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #11 Posted by Etienne Victoria on 14 Dec 2012, 6:42 p.m.,
in response to message #10 by Reth

Kidding I was, young padawan.

N, I and % indeed to The Dark Side of The Force belong...

The great RPN Jedis, The Beancounter will fight.

HP-80 rules !

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #12 Posted by Quan on 14 Dec 2012, 1:49 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

unshifted: sin  cos  tan  LN  LG   x_ROOT(y)
  shifted: asin acos atan e^x 1/x  y^x
      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #13 Posted by Dieter on 14 Dec 2012, 3:36 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

IMHO the 35s has a quite useful keyboard layout. I'd like to have something similar to its third row of keys. However, the 35s has two shift keys. If there is just one, I would say this is the most practical layout for general use:

  shifted: arcsin arccos arctan  x^2    e^x    y^x
unshifted:  sin    cos    tan    sqrt    ln    1/x
As to the six other functions: Phi(x) and Phi^-1(x) are used in most social sciences, so they are IMHO a "must" on a scientific calculator. While the parallel function can easily be replaced by a short user program (or a few simple keystrokes), this is not the case for the Normal CDF and its inverse. My suggestion for the second row, assuming "disp" sets the display mode and x! is actually Gamma(x+1):
  shifted: Phi^-1   x!    xroot  10^x   Round  User
unshifted:  Phi     %     log_x   lg    Disp   Alpha
No, I do not need any complex number support or rectangular/polar conversion functions.

By the way: what about an INV key?

Dieter

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #14 Posted by Eddie W. Shore on 14 Dec 2012, 3:45 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Quote:
Imagine the lower six rows of keys of our hypothetical eight-row calculator are filled with functions not listed below. Two rows are left. The following individual functions compete for the remaining space:

1/x SQRT LN e^x x^2 y^x LG 10^x i [theta] [Sigma+] [Sigma-] P>R R>P D>R R>D HR>H.MS H.MS>HR sin cos tan asin acos atan x_bar s y_hat r [parallel] % %CHG x_ROOT(y) LOG[sub_x](y) RAN# H.MS+ H.MS- x! COMB PERM ROUND DISP USER ALPHA DSE ISG ABS IP FP

What shall go there? You may specify up to 12 functions in your vote (one post only, please). You may specify them in pairs (unshifted / shifted) if you want to. You must not specify menus.

This poll will terminate on Tuesday, December 18th, at 12:12 UTC. Please participate.

d:-)


Unshifted: SQRT, SIN, COS, TAN, LN, >RECT

Shifted: x^2, ASIN, ACOS, ATAN, e^x, >POL

Edited: 14 Dec 2012, 3:45 p.m.

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #15 Posted by Mark Scheuern on 14 Dec 2012, 3:51 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Unshifted: sin cos tan sqrt e^x y^x

Shifted: asin acos atan x^2 ln 1/x

Edited: 14 Dec 2012, 3:53 p.m.

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #16 Posted by Michael de Estrada on 14 Dec 2012, 4:19 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

HYP, HYP<superscript>-1, L.R.

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #17 Posted by Bill Carter on 14 Dec 2012, 5:05 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Only 12 functions? The premise of this poll seems premature. The fundamental question of whether to load the keyboard top row or dedicate them to menu soft keys is still open, is it not?

It seems to me that the question(s) of keybpard loading are fundamental to the operation (or operability) of the calculator. My preference would be to "load" the keyboard. I would propose blue and yellow functions (in addition to the primary functions) for the second row. The top row would be re-assignable soft keys, but absent a menu call these keys would have assigned primary and yellow-shifted functions.

Loading the top row with a primary and shifted function (in addition to the soft key assignment) and adding a second shifted function to the second row would give us 30 spots (or 32, counting USER/ALPHA on the third row) and would cover most of the above list of potential functions. This is the question that should be answered first: load the keyboard, or not? Then, we debate the 18, 24, 30, or 32 most popular functions and their placement.

In case I'm alone in this, here are my 12 functions:

1. 1/x (I'd actually make this a data entry key along with +/-, EEX, and backspace, but surely >almost< all at least agree that it has to be on the keyboard. I'd make this a primary key.)

2. SQRT (This seems fundamental to me, and I'd like it to be primary. However with only 6 keys, I'd make it the yellow-shift of 1/x.)

3-8. SIN, COS, and TAN with shifted ASIN, ACOS, and ATAN.

9-10. LN with shifted e^x.

11. LG

12. y^x as the shifted function of LG. (I'd prefer 10^x be located on the LG key with y^x as a separate, primary key but real estate dictates.)

With the exception of #1, these are primary functions in that no closed-form calculation exists. With these functions and some stack, we can calculate most anything else that's missing, like H.MS, rect/polar, degrees/radians, TVM, parallel, and IP, FP. Some of these will be bigger losses in terms of convenience/usability than others, and this will vary by person. We >can<, however, get to them without menus. Unfortunately (and I see this as a major compromise) complex numbers, probability, and statistics are completely relegated to menus.

-Bill

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #18 Posted by Steve Perkins on 14 Dec 2012, 6:21 p.m.,
in response to message #17 by Bill Carter

I kind of agree with Bill here. There is so much not being asked, and much implied that many seem to have missed.

Since functions like USER and ALPHA are mentioned in the poll, this implies they are not assigned below already. They seem to be crucial to a sophisticated calculator like this is clearly going to be!

Given the layouts shown in other posts, I'm guessing many are assuming those are already present somewhere!?

Here are my choices given the constrains in the poll:

shifted: DISP   i    y^x  x^2   LN  SIGMA-
primary: USER ALPHA  1/x  SQRT  e^x SIGMA+

If in fact USER, ALPHA, DISP, or i are pre-assigned below as has been hinted at before, I'd try to fit the trig functions, giving up lower priority stuff like x^2, and pushing the SIGMAs to a menu, but as it is I couldn't fit some trigs but not others.

I sincerely hope the basic trig functions, as well as LG and 10^x are also available on the keyboard somehow. Since you only allowed me 12, I made the difficult choice.

                  
Why 'only' twelve?
Message #19 Posted by Walter B on 14 Dec 2012, 10:13 p.m.,
in response to message #18 by Steve Perkins

The simple reason is: I've to sum up your votes at the end of this poll; and I don't want to add let's say 40 times 50 functions - 40 times 12 is more convenient for me.

Side effect: this limit lets you feel the difficulty we feel all the time - we simply haven't enough real estate for all those nice functions you want to have, so we have to select. Same for you here.

Thanks for your understanding.

d:-)

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #20 Posted by Reth on 14 Dec 2012, 10:38 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

1/x SQRT x^2 y^x P>R R>P HR>H.MS H.MS>HR H.MS+ H.MS- USER ALPHA

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #21 Posted by Lyuka on 15 Dec 2012, 1:16 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

unshifted SQRT LOG  LN   y^x  1/x  sincos
shifted   x^2  10^x e^x  y^-x x/y  PI
Note:sincos calculates sin(x) and cos(x) simultaneously and stores sin(x) to y and cos(x) to x.

Lyuka

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #22 Posted by Paul Dale on 15 Dec 2012, 2:04 a.m.,
in response to message #21 by Lyuka

y-x and x/y seem weird. x<>y / is the same as x/y and in two keystrokes still -- okay slightly different LastX behaviour. yx 1/x or +/- yx are the same as y-x again subject to LastX.

Why not x-y as a function (reverse subtract) as well?

At least nobody has suggested xy yet :-) Must maintain HP 35 compatibility.

- Pauli

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #23 Posted by Paul Dale on 15 Dec 2012, 6:45 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

First thought:

sqrt, 1/x, x2, yx, USER, ALPHA, sigma+, sigma-, y1/x.

Rounds off with LOG, TRIG, CPX.

Unshifted: USER ALPHA, sigma+, LOG, TRIG. Probably CPX or 1/x.

But why not put all that powers into a menu too. We still get two key access to them which is no worse than a shift.

Unshifted: USER, ALPHA, sigma+, POWER, LOG, TRIG. Shifted: USER1, ALPHA1, sigma-, GAMMAs, HYP, ELLIPT.

Maybe swap out sigma+ for STATS or 1/x. Maybe call POWER PARTS or COMMON, SIMPLE-MATHS-FUNCTIONS.

My all time favourite HP, the 34c has almost all the mathematical functions shifted -- a top level menu and one further press is no different. The WP 34S also shifts the maths functions and we've no had major complaints about that either.

- Pauli

            
About USER/USER1 and ALPHA/ALPHA1
Message #24 Posted by Walter B on 16 Dec 2012, 2:49 a.m.,
in response to message #23 by Paul Dale

Pauli,

I admit I still don't understand why we should need all those four. Maybe I'm wrong but as far as I got it:

  • USER shall toggle user mode, so the user assignments come to the front.
  • ALPHA shall toggle alpha mode, so the grey letters come to the front.
  • ALPHA1 shall switch to alpha mode for input of a single character only, then return to the mode set before.
  • USER1 shall switch to user mode for input of a single operation only, then return to the mode set before.
Please confirm or correct.

d:-?

                  
Re: About USER/USER1 and ALPHA/ALPHA1
Message #25 Posted by Eric Smith on 16 Dec 2012, 3:15 a.m.,
in response to message #24 by Walter B

I disagree about how the distinction between USER and USER1 (or ALPHA and ALPHA1) occur. I prefer the HP-48 method: USER or USER1 are the same key. The behavior depends on the value of a flag.

The default after reset is that a single press of the USER key sets displays a USER1 annunciator and USER mode is active for a single following key sequence (other than another USER press), after which the USER1 annunciator is turned off, and normal mode is resumed.

If, from normal mode, USER is pressed twice consecutively, the first press sets USER1 as described above, but the second press changes the annunciator to USER (no "1"), and USER mode is "locked" on until the USER key is pressed again later, returning to normal mode.

If a "USER lock" flag is set, then a single press of the USER key enters USER lock, and the next USER press returns to normal.

I'm not really sure that ALPHA1 makes a lot of sense on this calculator, but if it is to be done, it should work similarly to USER1, except that I think the default setting should be the opposite (ALPHA lock enabled), and the user should have to clear the ALPHA lock flag to get ALPHA1 behavior.

USER1 is not very useful if it is a separate, shifted function, as it doesn't save keystrokes over the use of a locking USER key.

                        
Re: About USER/USER1 and ALPHA/ALPHA1
Message #26 Posted by Paul Dale on 16 Dec 2012, 3:18 a.m.,
in response to message #25 by Eric Smith

Yeah, the 48 method of press or double press is probably better than shifting one of the two flavours. Either way, a flag to toggle which occurs first is sensible I think.

- Pauli

                              
Re: About USER/USER1 and ALPHA/ALPHA1
Message #27 Posted by Raymond Del Tondo on 17 Dec 2012, 7:47 p.m.,
in response to message #26 by Paul Dale

I second that.

                  
Re: About USER/USER1 and ALPHA/ALPHA1
Message #28 Posted by Paul Dale on 16 Dec 2012, 3:17 a.m.,
in response to message #24 by Walter B

Correct for all four.

They are all useful in different ways.

With well thought our menus (including user defined), USER1 might end up redundant. ALPHA1 is probably less useful here than on the RPL machines it is derived -- this will depend on how we address named registers and locals.

- Pauli

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #29 Posted by Dieter on 16 Dec 2012, 10:23 a.m.,
in response to message #23 by Paul Dale

Quote:
My all time favourite HP, the 34c has almost all the mathematical functions shifted -- a top level menu and one further press is no different. The WP 34S also shifts the maths functions and we've no had major complaints about that either.
Both (34C and 34s) keyboards have only seven key rows, so even the most important math functions have to be shifted. That's what I like about the 41C and 35s - their additional 8th key row with these functions makes them much more convenient in everyday use. If the 43s hardware offers these additional keys as well, please use them for the most important math functions.

Dieter

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #30 Posted by Bill Carter on 17 Dec 2012, 1:33 a.m.,
in response to message #23 by Paul Dale

For me two-key access through a menu is >much< worse than a shift. The 28 was the only calculator I ever owned that I actively disliked. You're right in that it's the same number of keystrokes, so maybe it's just me.

Re the WP 34S: it's an amazing accomplishment, a technical wonder. The completeness of its function set and the accuracy it achieves on a limited hardware platform are remarkable. And it provides access to whole menus full of functionality I'll never need with the same number of keystrokes as the more basic functions that I use every day. Unfortunately, after some effort, I was not able to get comfortable with it. This marvel sits unused--I pick up a 15, a 42, a 48, or even a 35 instead. It's a shame.

I think my problem is this: I'm no mathematical slouch, but there among those whole menus of functions that I'll never use are many that I don't even know how to use, that I've never even heard of being used. Instead of being buried, they're just as accessible as the functions I use all day every day. They get in the way-- they get in >my< way, anyhow-- and negatively impact this wonder's usability. I thought it rude to "complain," but since you brought it up, this is how I feel.

If I had a solution to offer short of user-replaceable keys, I would. Lacking one, however, I'm left to advocate for what I see as essential: 1/x, sqrt, y^x, trigs, logs, and their inverses. While I don't use them regularly, sigma+ and i probably need permanent and prominent (primary key) placement to be really useful for those who do.

The WP 43S is proof that you can't give everybody everything that they want. But take the basic on-keyboard functionality of the 15, 41, or 42, add access to the advanced functionality of the WP 34S, and a user menu and you've made a living legend. Don't worry if some of the functions are a few levels deep-- if we need something esoteric we'll find it and with the ability to customize the menus, this becomes a non-issue. The 42 was almost there with two fewer keys overall, only one shift key, and a lesser display. You can do it!

-Bill

                  
WP 34S vs. 43S, menus and catalogs
Message #31 Posted by Walter B on 17 Dec 2012, 4:34 a.m.,
in response to message #30 by Bill Carter

The WP 34S does not feature menus and it never will. This is due to its breathtaking display (as mentioned here frequently). It provides catalogs instead. Cataloged functions may be accessed rapidly using the alphabetic search method described in the manual. This method works so well IMHO that we could have put all the functions in one large catalog there after all. We didn't do that, however, partly for historic reasons, partly since the practical knowledge of the alphabet is ... ummh ... found to be not as extensive as one should think.

The 43S will feature menus and only one catalog. A menu and a catalog are two completely different cups of tea. Please check the information given in earlier posts and you'll know what a menu is.

d:-)

                  
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #32 Posted by Paul Dale on 17 Dec 2012, 4:54 a.m.,
in response to message #30 by Bill Carter

From this description, it sounds like we shouldn't even be trying to design a 43S that you'll want to use. We're almost certainly going to have more features and functions than than the 34S, to cram those in we'll have to have menus of some kind -- things will have to be left off the keyboard I'm afraid. We're fairly committed to a user mode and an alpha mode and keeping everything else uncluttered would be nice as well. USER mode lets you put want you want where which ought to satisfy more people than us fixing the layout.

The 42S also has some shortcomings -- programming it can be painful, alpha entry is painful and there are many non-obvious functions in its menu system too.

- Pauli

                        
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #33 Posted by Bill Carter on 17 Dec 2012, 11:16 a.m.,
in response to message #32 by Paul Dale

Walter: I apologize for my sloppy use of terminology and stand corrected. Know that your educational efforts are not wasted; see how readily I've adapted to LG instead of LOG.

Pauli: I certainly didn't mean to offend. You've already designed a calculator that I >want< to use! I'm just offering my suggestions on how your design might be improved in its next incarnation. The WP 34S improves on the 42S's alpha entry without significant sacrifice. This is a major improvement! The improvements in programming are less useful to me because I'm willing to put up with a bit of pain while programming, but I see how this might be more important to others.

It sounds like the new machine will also be "improved" by omitting the third shift. Because my eye is really drawn to the green-shifted labels, I see this as a big improvement, but I recognize that the tradeoff is an effective loss of keyboard real estate. I think the team is on the right track.

One "improvement" relative to the 42S that's been discussed is not pre-loading the top row, instead keeping these keys clear for soft keys. This is something that I never found to be an issue on the 42S. When I'm in its ASSIGN or any other menu I see right past the key labels. With a primary and two shifted functions on each of the six second-row keys and a primary and either one or two (based on earlier information from Walter) shifted functions on the top row, there is enough real estate for a "good" and uncluttered layout. It's just a matter of defining the criteria for "good" that satisfy "most" people. After that, USER will be icing on the cake.

-Bill

                              
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #34 Posted by Marcus von Cube, Germany on 17 Dec 2012, 1:45 p.m.,
in response to message #33 by Bill Carter

I think, the reason why the 42S has the main functions of the top row printed on the keys is the relatively small display. In order to show two stack levels on the screen the menu line must be hidden most of the time. Without a menu line, the top row is useless, except if decorated with a set of default functions.

Compare this to the large screen devices (48 family) and the 17b or 27s. Both have a blank top row and permanent menus. Having permanent markings on these keys just doesn't make sense when the menu line is always shown.

                                    
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #35 Posted by Reth on 17 Dec 2012, 2:27 p.m.,
in response to message #34 by Marcus von Cube, Germany

Of course, top row keys under permanent menu line of the display shouldn't be labelled. I'm under the impression that the development team are trying to create the best of two worlds rather than amended HP42s

                                          
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #36 Posted by Walter B on 17 Dec 2012, 3:26 p.m.,
in response to message #35 by Reth

Just you wait a bit ;-)

            
What do you mean by that?
Message #37 Posted by Walter B on 17 Dec 2012, 5:50 a.m.,
in response to message #23 by Paul Dale

Pauli,

I do have difficulties counting your votes. Please read the OP again and clarify. Remember: no menus, 12 functions maximum.

d:-)

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #38 Posted by David Hayden on 15 Dec 2012, 10:35 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

unshifted: 1/x x^2 % USER ALPHA DISP
Shifted: sin cos tan asin acos atan

Dave

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #39 Posted by Reth on 16 Dec 2012, 5:09 a.m.,
in response to message #38 by David Hayden

Do you really want to see % as primary function?

                  
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #40 Posted by Walter B on 16 Dec 2012, 5:14 a.m.,
in response to message #39 by Reth

Seems he does. People are different. Else a function like %T never made it ;-)

                  
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #41 Posted by David Hayden on 16 Dec 2012, 8:41 a.m.,
in response to message #39 by Reth

I do. I think % is more useful to more people than the trig functions. I think high end calculators should add to the functionality of low end ones without taking anything away. % is a common function on low end calculators for a good reason.

Dave

            
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #42 Posted by Bill Carter on 17 Dec 2012, 1:41 a.m.,
in response to message #38 by David Hayden

And x^2 instead of sqrt? For the cost of a stack level and (assuming x^2 is primary instead of shifted) one keystroke, I can get to the square of x. I don't know another way (especially if logs and antilogs are absent) to get to the square root of x.

Not arguing, just curious.

-Bill

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #43 Posted by Antoine M. CouŰtte on 16 Dec 2012, 6:18 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

P>R R>P

Kermit

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #44 Posted by Morten Nygaard ┼snes on 16 Dec 2012, 9:29 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Unshifted: Sigma+  1/x  SQRT  LN   i     DISP
Shifted:   Sigma-  y^x  x^2   e^x  USER  ALPHA
      
Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #45 Posted by Walter B on 17 Dec 2012, 6:16 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

12 (10  2)  1/x           
12 (12  0)  SQRT 
11 ( 2  9)  x^2
11          sin cos tan / asin acos atan 
10 ( 4  6)  y^x 
 9          LN / e^x 
 7          P>R / R>P 
 5 ( 4  1)  ALPHA 
 5 ( 3  2)  USER 
 3          [Sigma+] / [Sigma-] 
 3          H.MS+ / H.MS- 
 3 ( 2  1)  DISP
 3          LG
 3          i
 3          % 
 2          IP / FP
 2          %CHG 
 1          HR>H.MS / H.MS>HR 
 1          10^x 
 1          [theta] 
 1          [parallel] 
 1          x_ROOT(y) 

d:-)

            
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #46 Posted by fhub on 17 Dec 2012, 10:55 a.m.,
in response to message #45 by Walter B

Two of the most important prefix keys (ALPHA and USER) only on place 8 and 9?
And the complex entry 'i' even far behind??

Well, I guess this 43s will not be a calculator for me ... :-(

Franz

Edited: 17 Dec 2012, 10:55 a.m.

                  
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #47 Posted by Reth on 17 Dec 2012, 2:16 p.m.,
in response to message #46 by fhub

If ALPHA and USER don't make it as primary I'll give it a miss too.

Looks like the biggest offender are trig functions - 6 out of 12 taken by them. I see no problem at all saving some 'real estate' by putting then in a menu.

Edited: 17 Dec 2012, 2:49 p.m.

                        
About polls and predictions
Message #48 Posted by Walter B on 17 Dec 2012, 3:17 p.m.,
in response to message #47 by Reth

That's the inevitable risk of polls: sometimes the results don't meet your expectations. Bad luck ;-) But there's still enough time to push some of your friends to the polling station.

And remember it won't be a calculator designed by a committee - we'll be looking to the results but won't follow them blindly.

d:-)

                              
Re: About polls and predictions
Message #49 Posted by fhub on 17 Dec 2012, 4:50 p.m.,
in response to message #48 by Walter B

Quote:
But there's still enough time to push some of your friends to the polling station.
Ok, so here's my vote for those 12 keys:
ALPHA ALPHA ALPHA ALPHA ALPHA ALPHA
USER  USER  USER  USER  USER  USER
:-)

Franz

                                    
Not that bad:-)
Message #50 Posted by Raymond Del Tondo on 17 Dec 2012, 6:03 p.m.,
in response to message #49 by fhub

no further text

                                          
My vote
Message #51 Posted by gene wright on 17 Dec 2012, 8:52 p.m.,
in response to message #50 by Raymond Del Tondo

ALPHA

and

USER

-- I agree. These really need to be primary functions, IMO.

            
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #52 Posted by Jeff O. on 17 Dec 2012, 1:16 p.m.,
in response to message #45 by Walter B

A problem is, a lot of people, myself included, would really like the trig functions to be on the keyboard. But they must* come or go as a group, so if you want them, that takes up six of the 12 available spots. I was willing to put them in a TRIGS menu, which would probably be active almost all of the time for me. That, plus my earlier choices in the poll, would cover about 99% of my normal use.

* - Obviously they do not have to come or go as a group, but most would expect to see all or none.

                  
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #53 Posted by Dave Shaffer (Arizona) on 17 Dec 2012, 5:45 p.m.,
in response to message #52 by Jeff O.

Unshifted: sin cos tan sqrt 1/x ln Shifted: arcsin arccos arctan ??? y^x e^x

As noted by others: x^2 can be easily accomplished, whereas sqrt(x) isn't quite as easy. If there is something more "valuable" it can be shifted sqrt.

% - I've never used this in forty years of calculator use.

                        
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #54 Posted by gene wright on 17 Dec 2012, 8:53 p.m.,
in response to message #53 by Dave Shaffer (Arizona)

I also would agree that square root as primary makes more sense to me than x^2

                              
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #55 Posted by ┴ngel Martin on 18 Dec 2012, 6:09 a.m.,
in response to message #54 by gene wright

and the end of the day and after endless polls and bizantine discussions it'll turn out the best keyboard is the 41's - and they didn't obliterate anybody's opinion, go figure

                                    
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #56 Posted by Maximilian Hohmann on 18 Dec 2012, 7:03 a.m.,
in response to message #55 by ┴ngel Martin

Quote:
... it'll turn out the best keyboard is the 41's ...

It cannot be the best because it has the basic arithmetic keys on the wrong side ;-) The best keyboard ever is the Ti59. If only Ti had been able to manufacture proper key contacts...

                                          
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #57 Posted by Walter B on 18 Dec 2012, 7:58 a.m.,
in response to message #56 by Maximilian Hohmann

@Maximilian: Sch÷nheit liegt im Auge des Betrachters.

@Angel: You don't know anything about the polls and discussions at HP before the 41 was launched, do you?

d:-)

                                                
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #58 Posted by ┴ngel Martin on 18 Dec 2012, 10:31 a.m.,
in response to message #57 by Walter B

Quote:
You don't know anything about the polls and discussions at HP before the 41 was launched, do you?

Much more than you can possibly think...

                                                      
Re: Counts so far - hardly 25h to go
Message #59 Posted by Michael Kussmaul on 18 Dec 2012, 11:40 a.m.,
in response to message #58 by ┴ngel Martin

:-) I miss-read you comment like:

"Much more than you can possibly drink..."

Who knows, what really happened at HP at that time :-)

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #60 Posted by Harald on 17 Dec 2012, 7:39 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

un-shifted: 1/x  sqrt(x)  e^x   ln  y^x  i
shifted:     ??  x^2      10^x  lg; ??   < (polar entry of complex umbers)

Edited: 17 Dec 2012, 7:41 a.m.

      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #61 Posted by Bart (UK) on 17 Dec 2012, 7:49 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Unshifted:  %     y^x     i     IP  P>R  H.MS>HR
shifted  :  %CHG  LG   [theta]  FP  R>P  HR>H.MS
      
Re: What are the most popular functions? (Poll until 18.12.)
Message #62 Posted by Derek Walker (UK) on 17 Dec 2012, 8:45 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

Unshifted / Shifted:
Sin / Asin
Cos / Acos
Tan / Atan
x^2 / sqrt x
y^x / xth root of y
1/x / ??

No strong views on the last space, those above cover what I use most.

      
Results of the poll about function popularity
Message #63 Posted by Walter B on 18 Dec 2012, 8:18 a.m.,
in response to message #1 by Walter B

15 (14  1)  SQRT 
15 (12  2)  1/x           
14 ( 7  7)  y^x 
13          sin cos tan / asin acos atan 
13 ( 3 10)  x^2
11          LN / e^x 
 8          P>R / R>P 
 7 ( 6  1)  ALPHA 
 7 ( 4  3)  USER 
 5          i
 5          LG
 4          % 
 3          [Sigma+] / [Sigma-] 
 3          H.MS+ / H.MS- 
 3          [theta] 
 3          DISP
 3          IP / FP
 3          %CHG 
 2          10^x 
 2          HR>H.MS / H.MS>HR 
 2          x_ROOT(y) 
 1          [parallel] 

... if I counted correctly. Thanks for participating.

d:-)


[ Return to Index | Top of Index ]

Go back to the main exhibit hall