Re: Can't be an Edsel -- Doesn't have the same grille . . . Message #3 Posted by Paul Brogger on 16 Jan 2004, 5:13 p.m., in response to message #1 by Benjamin
My first unit (ser. # CN331nnnnn) had two sticky keys -- I kept with it for a couple of weeks, then politely [maybe that helps?] asked for a replacement. The second unit (ser. # CN333nnnnn) works great.
Before returning it, I tried the "push & wiggle" cure on the first unit, and lo & behold, it actually fixed the keys! (I've heard of others who have had good luck with this, as well as some who haven't.)
Now, I agree that if HP had come out with a more reliable keyboard, a LOT of bad vibes could have been avoided. But I'm completely satisfied with my new unit. The increased speed, USB connection, and SD card storage are all great improvements. I understand that the hard keys, plastic display window and documentation are all great improvements over those of the 49G, but I never owned one of those.
In its construction, it's no HP-41, but it has great power & features for the price. It's not perfect, but user group support (through COMP.SYS.HP48) and the expected-but-not-explicitly-promised Flash upgrades should help with that over time.
Judging from the many reactions I've heard so far, I offer this:
If you weren't happy with the 49G, but used it anyway, you'll almost certainly love the 49G+. Buy with confidence.
If you use HP-48's regularly, there's probably a better than 50/50 chance that you'll like the 49G. Buy with a clear understanding of the return policy.
If you hate RPL and don't think H-P has done anything right since the HP-41, then you'll hate the HP-49G. Go to eBay and dig up another HP-41CX.
|