The Museum of HP Calculators

HP Forum Archive 07

[ Return to Index | Top of Index ]

HP41CV math and advantage module conflict?
Message #1 Posted by Glenn McEnroe on 5 Mar 2002, 10:21 p.m.

I have an HP41CV with a math I module and advantage module. I noticed that the order of placement of the modules make a differance as to whether they work together or not. Is there a conflict in having both modules installed simultaneously? I noticed they have some similar capabilities but some individual as well. For instance I could not run the SOLVE function (from math I) when it is placed after the advantage module with an error, NONEXISTANT. Just curious if I have missed something here having not read all the manuals.

Thanks, Glenn

      
Re: HP41CV math and advantage module conflict?
Message #2 Posted by Glenn McEnroe on 5 Mar 2002, 10:49 p.m.,
in response to message #1 by Glenn McEnroe

I figured this out. Read the manual, looks like these pacs do conflict with each other, the advantage pac is more capable so I will probably put the math pac out to bid on ebay.

Glenn

            
Re: HP41CV math and advantage module conflict?
Message #3 Posted by Yani on 6 Mar 2002, 5:27 a.m.,
in response to message #2 by Glenn McEnroe

I quote from the HP-41 ADVANTAGE manual p16.

"Certain function names used by the HP-41 Advantage are also used by the HP-41 Math Pac and the HP-41 Real Estate Pac. When using these functions you should remove the module whose functions you do not want accessed."

For the Math Pac the functions listed are;

All complex number functions and all functions in DIFEQ.

Hope this helps.

BTW there is a conflict with the HP-IL Development module such that the manual recomends that the two modules must not be plugged in at the same time. They share the same id numbers.

                  
Re: HP41CV math and advantage module conflict?
Message #4 Posted by Glenn McEnroe on 6 Mar 2002, 11:26 a.m.,
in response to message #3 by Yani

Yes there are a number of other functions shared by the 2 pacs besides complex number functions and all functions in DIFEQ which are not mentioned in the manual.

Glenn

                        
Re: HP41CV math and advantage module conflict?
Message #5 Posted by Wlodek Mier-Jedrzejowicz on 6 Mar 2002, 6:33 p.m.,
in response to message #4 by Glenn McEnroe

If you _need_ to use functions from both modules in a program, and you reach a program step where you want to enter the name of a function which exists in _both_ modules, then:

Turn the HP-41 off. Take out one of the modules - keep only the one whose function you want plugged in. Turn the HP-41 back on, enter program mode, put the function you want into the program. Since only one module is plugged in, there is no conflict. Now you can carry on entering the program. When you need to, turn the HP-41 off and put in the other module.

Although the function _names_ are the same, the program steps actually contain an XROM command, which will be different, depending on which module was plugged in when the program step was entered. When you run the program, both modules can be plugged in and the program will still work.

Things are less clear-cut if you try to execute a function whose name is in both modules, from the keyboard - the function is picked from the module in the lower-numbered port. To override this, assign the function to a USER mode key, with only the module you want plugged in. The command will then work when you press that key even if both modules are later plugged in.

The worst-case scenarion is where different functions have the same XROM number! But that's a different topic.

Keep those HP-41s working!

Wlodek Mier-Jedrzejowicz

                              
Re: HP41CV math and advantage module conflict?
Message #6 Posted by yani.nospam@youydsa.info on 7 Mar 2002, 2:50 a.m.,
in response to message #5 by Wlodek Mier-Jedrzejowicz

Of course you could use synthetic programming to enter the xrom code directly into your programme!


[ Return to Index | Top of Index ]

Go back to the main exhibit hall